NFL Week 10 Picks: The Good, the Bad, and the Costanza
NFLPreview🔥 HOT

NFL Week 10 Picks: The Good, the Bad, and the Costanza

OFS JoeOFS Joe
Nov 14, 20260

We’re past the halfway mark. The contenders are separating themselves, the pretenders are getting exposed, and the New York Jets are 2-7 like it’s a family tradition passed down through generations.

This week, we’ve got football in Germany before most Americans have brushed their teeth, a Kirk Cousins comeback tour, a game in Indianapolis that should come with a complimentary sleeping pill, and a Costanza pick that would make George himself stand up and applaud.

Six plays on the card. Some make perfect sense. Others require a little faith, a little stupidity, and the willingness to watch two terrible football teams attempt to score points.

Grab a coffee. Or a bratwurst if you’re watching the early game properly.

Lions -2.5 vs. Patriots (Munich, 9:30 a.m.)

Nothing says Sunday morning football quite like bratwurst at 9:30 a.m. and Drake Maye throwing the football to the wrong team.

New England is flying 4,000 miles to face one of the NFL’s most explosive offenses with a secondary that couldn’t cover a restaurant check.

The Patriots allow 260.9 passing yards per game, dead last in the league, and sit at minus 11 in turnover differential, tied for 31st. That’s not a pass defense. That’s a welcome mat with cleats.

And somehow, the numbers don’t even tell the whole story.

New England surrendered seven explosive passing plays in Week 9, six of them going for at least 20 yards. Now they get Jared Goff, Amon-Ra St. Brown, and a Detroit offense that can turn a routine five yard slant into a 60 yard touchdown before you’ve finished buttering your toast.

Maye has a cannon for an arm. Unfortunately, he occasionally forgets which color jersey his teammates are wearing. Three first half interceptions against Green Bay is the kind of performance that makes a head coach consider pulling a random guy out of the stands.

And it’s not like Maye has an elite receiving corps to bail him out.

New England’s receivers are so bad that if you put them on Facebook Marketplace, you’d get three views, two scam messages, and an offer to haul them away for free.

Maye could throw a perfect 50 yard dime, and there’s a better chance of the ball being caught by a German tourist holding a bratwurst than one of his own receivers.

And the Patriots aren’t exactly arriving in Germany at full strength.

Offensive lineman Ben Brown, cornerback Carlton Davis, and running back TreVeyon Henderson are all out. So we’re asking a young quarterback to win a game in a foreign country, at an hour when his body thinks he should still be asleep, against a team that can score 30 points without breaking a sweat.

Sounds like a terrific plan.

Detroit, meanwhile, is rolling. The Lions held Miami to 182 total yards and zero touchdowns in Week 9. Their offense is dangerous, their defense is capable of taking over games, and Jake Bates has scored at least seven points in every contest. Even when the offense stalls, they’re putting something on the scoreboard.

Now, I’m not going to pretend Detroit is flawless.

The defense has its own injury concerns, and the underlying metrics aren’t exactly a work of art. If Maye manages to protect the football, this could turn into a 31-28 shootout where nobody bothers playing defense after halftime.

But Dan Campbell is the kind of lunatic who would bite somebody’s kneecap in the middle of an Oktoberfest tent and then ask for another beer.

His team isn’t getting jet lagged out of this one.

We’re getting one of the league’s worst pass defenses against one of its best offenses, and all we have to lay is 2.5?

I’ll take my chances.

The Pick: Lions -2.5

Detroit wins by a touchdown. Somebody hand Dan Campbell a bratwurst.

Prost.

Falcons +3.5 vs. Chiefs

Here’s my gut feeling about Kansas City.

The Chiefs are 6-2, but they don’t exactly look like a team interested in blowing anybody out right now.

They’re winning games, sure. But there’s a difference between winning football games and looking like the unstoppable machine that used to make the rest of the AFC contemplate switching professions.

And now Patrick Mahomes has an elbow problem.

Mahomes briefly left Week 9 with an injury and was scheduled for additional testing. When the guy with the $450 million arm is getting his elbow scanned, I’m at least interested in taking the points on the other side.

Xavier Worthy also left with a hamstring injury, while tackle Jaylon Moore exited with an ankle issue.

So potentially we’re looking at a quarterback with a sore throwing arm, a missing deep threat, and an offensive line held together by athletic tape and Andy Reid’s mustache.

That’s not the 2019 Chiefs.

That’s a minivan with the check engine light on.

Now, Atlanta isn’t exactly arriving here looking like the 2007 Patriots.

The Falcons just got embarrassed 34-17 by Cincinnati in Madrid. They scored on their first two possessions, apparently decided that was enough football for one afternoon, and proceeded to spend the rest of the game collecting penalties like frequent flyer miles.

Twelve penalties. A season high.

That’s not discipline. That’s a group of grown men desperately trying to get back to the hotel buffet.

But there were positives.

Bijan Robinson finished with 147 scrimmage yards, reminding everybody that he’s still one of the most dangerous players in football. Michael Penix Jr. also rushed for a career high 50 yards, which is a sentence I never expected to write.

Nobody had Penix turning into Lamar Jackson on their bingo card.

The concern here is Kansas City’s pass rush.

The Chiefs pressured the quarterback on half of his dropbacks against the Jets and recorded five sacks. If Atlanta falls behind early and Penix has to throw 40 times, he’s going to spend more time on the ground than the midfield logo.

That’s why the game plan needs to be painfully simple.

Give Bijan the football. Then give it to him again. Then, when everyone in the stadium knows what’s coming, give it to him a third time.

Twenty five touches. Shorten the game. Keep Mahomes standing on the sideline watching.

We’re getting the home team, more than a field goal, and a Kansas City team that hasn’t exactly been destroying people.

I don’t need Atlanta to win.

I need them to be annoying enough to hang around for 60 minutes.

The Pick: Falcons +3.5

Chiefs can win 23-20. Andy Reid celebrates with a cheeseburger, Mahomes gets his ice pack, and we cash our ticket.

Everybody goes home happy.

Except Atlanta, obviously.

Vikings +3 at Packers

The Minnesota Vikings went from Carson Wentz to Kirk Cousins this week.

That’s not just a quarterback change.

That’s upgrading from a 1998 Ford Taurus with 240,000 miles to a perfectly respectable Toyota Camry that still has another 100,000 miles left in it.

Wentz’s last start was less of a football game and more of a hostage video.

Eight completions on 25 attempts. Eighty one yards. Two interceptions. A lost fumble.

And the Vikings went 0-for-8 on third down against Buffalo.

ZERO FOR EIGHT.

You could’ve put a golden retriever behind center, handed him a Milk Bone, and probably gone 1-for-8.

Enter Kirk Cousins.

Kirk returns to Minnesota like an ex boyfriend showing up at your front door with a fresh haircut, a better job, and a suspicious amount of confidence.

He went 202 for 315 for 2,340 yards, 20 touchdowns, and eight interceptions in nine starts with Las Vegas.

That’s actual NFL quarterback production. Something Minnesota fans probably thought had been discontinued.

Officially, the Vikings haven’t committed to Cousins starting. But Green Bay head coach Matt LaFleur apparently decided to make the announcement for them.

“He’ll be starting… I’m fairly confident of that.”

Thanks, Matt. Very helpful.

And Cousins knows Green Bay.

Sunday will mark his 12th career start against the Packers. He knows the stadium, knows the rivalry, and probably knows which bathroom has the shortest line at halftime.

But the real reason I like Minnesota is the defense.

The Vikings have 29 sacks, nine interceptions, and a plus five turnover differential. They’ve also managed to turn Jared Goff and Josh Allen into ordinary fantasy quarterbacks.

That’s not easy.

Meanwhile, Green Bay’s running game has taken a hit. Josh Jacobs needs surgery on a fractured finger, with no established return timeline.

So the Packers are suddenly asking somebody else’s cousin to carry the football.

And no, not Kirk.

Now, Jordan Love deserves his flowers.

He’s thrown for 2,618 yards, 19 touchdowns, and six interceptions. Christian Watson has 879 receiving yards and seven touchdowns. Green Bay can absolutely move the football through the air.

They also outgained Minnesota 419 to 239 in their Week 1 meeting, a 39-22 victory that wasn’t nearly as competitive as the final score might suggest.

But here’s the thing.

Green Bay allowed Carson Wentz to throw three touchdowns in that game.

Carson Wentz.

Now they’re facing a quarterback who actually knows how to do that on purpose.

Divisional rivalry. Lambeau Field in November. A line that was established while Minnesota’s quarterback room looked like an open casting call for a low budget disaster movie.

And Kirk Cousins gets another opportunity to remind everybody that he’s still employed for a reason.

I like the Vikings to hang around all afternoon.

An outright win wouldn’t shock me one bit.

The Pick: Vikings +3

Kirk Cousins revenge tour, stop number one.

You like that?

Jets/Bills Over 50

The Buffalo Bills are 7-1.

The New York Jets are 2-7.

And somewhere in Western New York, Josh Allen is preparing to take out his frustrations on a defense that probably hasn’t done anything to deserve what’s coming.

Actually, scratch that.

It’s the Jets. They’ve done plenty.

Allen is coming off his worst fantasy performance of the season against Minnesota. And if there’s one thing I don’t want to face, it’s Josh Allen coming off a game where he looked mortal.

Nobody enjoys an angry Josh Allen.

Except people holding over tickets.

Buffalo leads the NFL in total offense at 386.4 yards per game and scoring at 32 points per game.

James Cook ranks fifth in the league with 814 rushing yards and has already topped 100 yards four times.

The Bills can beat you on the ground, through the air, or with Allen deciding he’s tired of throwing the football and would rather run over a linebacker.

It’s a choose your own adventure book where every ending involves the defense getting embarrassed.

But here’s why I like the over instead of simply laying the points with Buffalo.

The Jets can contribute.

I know. I can’t believe I’m writing that either.

Geno Smith, now 36 years old, is quietly having a respectable season. He’s fifth in completion percentage at 67.5% and seventh in passer rating at 100.5.

The Jets have also scored on their opening possession in five consecutive games, the longest active streak in the NFL.

They start games like a legitimate football team.

Then, somewhere around the second quarter, they remember they’re the Jets.

And that’s actually a beautiful thing for an over.

Give me an early Jets touchdown, Buffalo responding with 24 unanswered points, and Geno throwing for his life in the fourth quarter.

That’s the recipe.

Breece Hall is back, too. He returned from a five game absence with 61 rushing yards against Kansas City, giving New York another legitimate offensive weapon.

Buffalo’s offensive line also has concerns, with Dion Dawkins dealing with a rib injury and Alec Anderson nursing an ankle issue.

Normally, offensive line injuries would make me nervous about an over.

But with Josh Allen, sometimes a collapsing pocket just means we’re about to witness something ridiculous.

He escapes, scrambles for 17 yards, stiff arms a defensive back, and somehow turns a busted play into a touchdown.

Chaos.

Beautiful, beautiful chaos.

There is one legitimate concern, and it’s a big one.

Garrett Wilson.

Without Wilson, the Jets managed only 229 total yards against Kansas City. That’s not an offense. That’s a group chat where nobody responds.

If Wilson can’t go, I become significantly less enthusiastic about this play.

His availability matters.

But assuming he’s in the lineup, I see Buffalo doing most of the heavy lifting while the Jets contribute enough points to get us across the finish line.

And we’re getting 50 instead of the 50.5 to 51.5 floating around elsewhere.

That half point matters.

The Pick: Jets/Bills Over 50

Bills 34, Jets 20.

Josh Allen gets his bounce back game, the Jets find another creative way to lose, and everybody holding an over ticket goes to bed smiling.

Dolphins +3.5 at Colts

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the football equivalent of spending three hours at the DMV.

Miami is 1-7.

Indianapolis is 2-7.

Between these two teams, we’ve got three wins, a collection of questionable quarterback decisions, and enough offensive incompetence to make the forward pass look like a failed experiment.

If you’re watching this game voluntarily, I hope somebody is paying you.

Bring a book.

Preferably a long one.

But here’s the beauty of betting football.

We don’t get paid based on entertainment value.

We get paid based on the number.

And I have absolutely no interest in laying more than a field goal with this Indianapolis Colts team.

The Colts have lost five straight games. Daniel Jones has thrown an interception in eight of nine contests, including four consecutive games.

At this point, throwing the football to the other team isn’t a mistake.

It’s part of the offensive playbook.

Indianapolis is averaging just 23.3 yards per drive over its last four games, ranking 31st in the NFL.

That’s not moving the chains.

That’s moving the punter into position.

And somehow we’re supposed to trust this team to win by more than a field goal?

That’s like co-signing a loan for your cousin who says he’s starting a business but won’t tell you what the business actually does.

No thank you.

Miami, meanwhile, is making another quarterback change.

Malik Willis aggravated his groin injury badly enough to land on injured reserve, leaving second year quarterback Kyle McCord to make the start.

Now, I’m not going to sit here and tell you Kyle McCord is the second coming of Dan Marino.

I’m not even going to tell you he’s the second coming of Chad Henne.

But sometimes there’s an advantage to starting a quarterback nobody has seen enough of to properly hate yet.

There’s no extensive NFL tape to pick apart.

No established reputation to destroy.

Just a young guy trying to survive behind an offensive line while his coaches pray he doesn’t throw the football directly into a defender’s chest.

And fortunately for Miami, the Colts have a very obvious weakness.

They can’t stop the run.

Indianapolis allows 4.93 yards per carry, ranking 29th in the league.

Miami averages 4.37 yards per attempt, with Ollie Gordon leading the charge.

That’s the entire game plan.

Run the ball.

Run it again.

Maybe throw a five yard pass if we’re feeling adventurous.

Punt.

Play defense.

Repeat until somebody mercifully blows the final whistle.

It’s not going to be pretty.

But neither is anything involving these two teams.

The biggest concern is Miami’s red zone offense.

The Dolphins have zero passing touchdowns in the red zone this season.

Zero.

That’s almost impressive.

You’d think one would happen accidentally. A tipped ball, a blown coverage, somebody slipping on a banana peel.

Something.

But no.

Miami might need four field goals, a defensive touchdown, and divine intervention to get this done.

The Colts also beat Miami 33-8 last season and have won three straight meetings.

Wonderful.

Congratulations.

That was then.

This is a Colts team that has apparently forgotten how to win football games.

I’m taking the points in a game that should probably be played behind closed doors to protect the public.

The Pick: Dolphins +3.5

Dolphins 23-Colts 21 .

Nobody deserves to win. Nobody looks particularly happy afterward.

But we win.

And that’s all that matters.

COSTANZA PICK OF THE WEEK: Cowboys +4.5 vs. 49ers

Sometimes the only way to make sense of the NFL is to abandon logic entirely.

That’s where George Costanza comes in.

Every natural instinct I have tells me San Francisco should win this football game comfortably.

The 49ers are 7-1 with a plus 79 point differential.

Dallas is 4-5 and has allowed 236 points in nine games.

Brock Purdy is in the MVP conversation.

San Francisco has covered the spread in each of the last four meetings between these teams.

And the Cowboys defense tackles like a bunch of uncles playing touch football at a family barbecue after six beers.

Everything screams San Francisco.

Which is precisely why we’re taking Dallas.

As George Costanza once discovered, when every instinct you have is wrong, the opposite would have to be right.

Chicken salad on rye. Untoasted. Cup of tea.

Let’s get to work.

First, San Francisco’s injury report looks like the guest list for a hospital fundraiser.

Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel, Deommodore Lenoir, and Renardo Green are all questionable.

That’s a significant chunk of the receiving corps and both starting outside cornerbacks potentially compromised.

Not exactly ideal when you’re facing Dak Prescott.

And Dak, to his credit, is playing some pretty good football.

He threw for 335 yards and two touchdowns in last week’s victory over Indianapolis and has produced three consecutive top 10 fantasy performances.

I know. Dak Prescott playing well in November.

Somebody check the calendar.

But here’s the thing about Dak.

Give him time in the pocket, a couple of backup cornerbacks, and a home crowd, and suddenly he starts looking like the quarterback Jerry Jones has been telling us he is for the last decade.

It’s like watching a guy who normally pays full retail walk into Costco and discover everything is on sale.

He can’t help himself.

There’s also plenty of desperation on the Dallas sideline.

The Cowboys are 4-5, but somehow they’re still alive in the NFC East, sitting within striking distance of the 5-2-1 Giants.

Only in the NFC East could a team with a losing record, a questionable defense, and an owner who treats every press conference like a personal podcast still have legitimate playoff aspirations.

Lose this game and Dallas might as well start reserving tee times.

Win it, and Jerry Jones will be on the radio Monday morning explaining why this team has everything it takes to win the Super Bowl.

He’ll probably announce another contract extension before lunch.

Now let’s talk about the total.

This game is sitting at 55.5, which tells you everything you need to know about what kind of afternoon we’re expecting.

Points.

Lots of them.

The over has hit in six of nine Dallas games this season, and the Cowboys defense has been generous enough to qualify for charitable status.

But big totals can also be beautiful for an underdog catching points.

More scoring means more possessions. More possessions mean more opportunities for a late touchdown. And more opportunities for a late touchdown mean more chances for Dak Prescott to ruin somebody’s afternoon with a meaningless scoring drive.

Picture it.

San Francisco leads 31-17 midway through the fourth quarter.

The 49ers start playing prevent defense, their backup cornerbacks are giving receivers ten yards of cushion, and Dak suddenly turns into prime Peyton Manning against a defense that’s already mentally on the team bus.

A touchdown here. A stop there.

Next thing you know, Dallas is within a field goal, and everybody who laid 4.5 with San Francisco is screaming at the television.

That’s the beauty of the Costanza.

We’re not necessarily betting on the better football team.

We’re betting against common sense.

And common sense has a pretty terrible record in this league.

Jerry Jones will be standing on the sideline doing whatever Jerry Jones does, Mike McCarthy will look like he just ate something that disagreed with him, and George Costanza will be somewhere smiling.

The Pick: Cowboys +4.5

49ers 31, Cowboys 28.

“My whole life I’ve done the exact opposite of what I should do.”

Cowboys plus the points.

Lock it.

The Final Card

  • Lions -2.5 vs. Patriots
  • Falcons +3.5 vs. Chiefs
  • Vikings +3 at Packers
  • Jets/Bills Over 50
  • Dolphins +3.5 at Colts
  • COSTANZA PICK OF THE WEEK: Cowboys +4.5 vs. 49ers

Six games. Six opportunities to look like a genius or spend Sunday night questioning every decision that led us here.

We’ve got football in Germany, a quarterback reunion in Green Bay, a potential track meet in Buffalo, and a game in Indianapolis that might qualify as cruel and unusual punishment.

And of course, we’ve got George Costanza riding shotgun in Dallas.

Enjoy the games, drink your coffee on Munich time, and remember that sometimes the smartest thing you can do in the NFL is the exact opposite of what makes sense.

If that doesn’t work, just blame the Jets.

Everybody else does.

OFS JoeOFS Joe

Read Next