CFB Week 12 Preview: The Good, The Bad, and The Unwatchable
College FootballPreviewđŸ”„ HOT

CFB Week 12 Preview: The Good, The Bad, and The Unwatchable

OFS JoeOFS Joe
Nov 20, 20260

Rivalry week is next week, which means this Saturday is the part of the college football season where everybody’s looking ahead, half the country is already arguing about the playoff, and the sportsbooks are perfectly happy to take your money while you’re distracted.

Not us. We’ve got six plays, a couple of unders that should qualify as cruel and unusual punishment, and a Costanza pick that requires ignoring just about everything your brain tells you. We’ve got undefeated teams laying uncomfortable numbers, home dogs nobody wants to touch, and two games where completing a forward pass might be considered an act of aggression.

Some of these games will be beautiful. Others should come with a warning from the Surgeon General. We’re betting them anyway.

Let’s go lose some friends.

WASHINGTON +8.5 vs. Indiana

Indiana is 9-1 and 2-8 against the spread. Before the Hoosier faithful flood my mentions, yes, both covers came in the last two weeks, including a 27-13 handling of USC. Congratulations. You’ve cashed two tickets all season and the market reacted like you invented the forward pass. This is the guy at the poker table who wins two hands in a row and starts telling everyone he’s going pro. Two covers is a heater, not a personality.

Washington comes in ranked 28th in defensive success rate and 26th in opponent EPA per play, and Demond Williams Jr. has thrown 13 touchdowns against just four interceptions. He’s the kind of quarterback who can keep his team competitive without handing the other side three extra possessions. That’s especially important against an Indiana team that would love nothing more than to get ahead early and make you play its game.

Then there’s the setting. Husky Stadium in late November isn’t exactly a vacation destination, and with a total sitting in the low 40s, every point matters. Indiana deserves respect for what it’s accomplished, but there’s a difference between being the better football team and being worth more than a touchdown on the road. You don’t lay 8.5 in a game where both offenses might end up shopping at the same Marshalls.

Indiana probably wins this game. Indiana probably doesn’t cover it. Indiana fans will DM me either way, and I’m already looking forward to the thoughtful, well-reasoned discussion.

Pick: Washington +8.5

BOSTON COLLEGE +3 vs. Syracuse

This isn’t a football game. It’s two guys arguing over who has the worse car, except neither one realizes they’re both driving a 2006 Nissan Altima with the check engine light on.

My rule in these situations is simple: when both teams stink, take the points and look away. Syracuse has spent much of the season living on the edge, with games decided by a possession and enough late drama to make every Orange fan eligible for a cardiology referral. At some point, when you’re constantly asking the football gods for one more break, the football gods stop answering the phone.

Boston College has had the better of this matchup recently, winning four of the last six meetings, including a 34-12 beatdown last November. The Eagles also have a win over Pitt, a team Syracuse couldn’t handle. None of that makes Boston College a powerhouse. It just makes the idea of laying a field goal with Syracuse considerably less appealing.

And that’s really the handicap here. We’re not asking Boston College to look like Alabama. We’re asking the Eagles to hang around against a team that hasn’t exactly made a habit of putting opponents away. If this turns into the ugly, disorganized mess it has every right to become, I’ll gladly take the three points.

Nobody should voluntarily watch this game. Everybody should consider taking the Eagles. Sometimes the best handicapping strategy is accepting that two bad teams are going to play bad football and making sure you’re holding the points when they do.

Pick: Boston College +3

KANSAS +5.5 vs. BYU

BYU is the better football team. Kansas apparently hasn’t been informed.

The Jayhawks have beaten BYU in each of their last two meetings, winning 17-13 in Provo and 38-27 in Lawrence. Now they get the Cougars at home again, with senior day providing a little extra motivation for a Kansas team that would love nothing more than to ruin somebody else’s season.

Kansas averages 30.2 points per game, which is a legitimate offense and not some cute statistic I dug up to justify betting a mediocre team. The Jayhawks can move the football, and when they’re competitive, they have a habit of making life miserable for whoever happens to be on the other sideline. Their close losses to TCU and UCF are reminders that this team doesn’t need to be better than its opponent for 60 minutes to make covering a number difficult.

BYU is good, and I’m not interested in pretending otherwise. The Cougars allow just 18.5 points per game and have earned their position near the top of the conference. But good teams can still be overpriced, particularly on the road against opponents with enough offense to keep things interesting.

Five and a half points sits right in that sweet spot where BYU wins by a field goal after you’ve aged three years watching the fourth quarter. Kansas has enough offensive firepower to make this uncomfortable, and I wouldn’t be surprised if the Jayhawks are hanging around with a chance to win late.

Give me the home dog, the points, and whatever medication is necessary to survive the final five minutes.

Pick: Kansas +5.5

IOWA/ILLINOIS UNDER 40.5

Iowa football. Where the forward pass goes to retire, take up pickleball, and complain about property taxes.

The Hawkeyes throw for just 198.9 yards per game, ranking 98th nationally, and they could not be prouder of themselves. Why bother throwing the football when you can punt, play defense, and slowly drain the will to live out of everyone watching? It’s a philosophy that’s been passed down through generations in Iowa City, and apparently nobody has the authority to stop it.

The defense, on the other hand, is genuinely outstanding. Iowa allows just 11.7 points per game, the best mark in the country, and has held every opponent below its season scoring average. Not most opponents. Every single one. That’s the kind of consistency you want when you’re betting an under and praying nobody decides to get creative.

Illinois has its own offensive concerns. With uncertainty surrounding the quarterback situation and Hudson Clement unavailable, the Illini aren’t exactly positioned to turn this into a track meet. If Carson Boyd gets the start, asking him to consistently move the ball against this Iowa defense is a pretty miserable assignment.

Seven of Iowa’s first ten games finished below this number, and the matchup points toward another afternoon of punts, field goals, and third downs that feel like hostage negotiations. A 20-10 final wouldn’t surprise me, although it might somehow take six hours to get there.

The biggest danger is a defensive or special teams touchdown, particularly with Braeden Jackson already having taken two kickoffs to the house this season. That’s the kind of nonsense that can destroy an otherwise perfect under without either offense doing anything remotely impressive.

If you’re watching this game live, bring a book. Bring two. You might finish both before Iowa completes a pass longer than 15 yards.

Pick: Under 40.5

UCLA/MICHIGAN UNDER 38

Michigan’s passing game has spent stretches of this season operating like it’s in witness protection. Against Oregon, its quarterbacks combined for just 71 passing yards. Seventy-one. I’ve thrown for more than that in a backyard game while holding a beer, and nobody was offering me a scholarship.

The Wolverines have struggled to generate consistent offense, and changing the man calling the plays doesn’t magically fix a unit that has spent much of the year making moving the chains look like advanced calculus. Now they face a UCLA defense that has been creating turnovers and making opponents work for everything. That’s a particularly unpleasant matchup when your passing attack already needs a search party.

The Bruins aren’t necessarily interested in turning this into a shootout either. They control possession, take their time, and have had their own problems finishing drives in the red zone. That combination is exactly what I want when I’m holding an under. Long possessions that end in field goals are beautiful things, even if watching them makes you question why you enjoy football in the first place.

Michigan has repeatedly found itself in low-scoring games, and this matchup has the ingredients for another one. Both teams have reasons to lean on defense, protect field position, and avoid giving away possessions. Nobody needs to reinvent football here. Just run the ball, punt when necessary, and leave the scoreboard operator alone.

This has 9-6 or 12-10 written all over it. The kind of final score that makes kickers feel like Heisman candidates and leaves the television audience wondering whether somebody accidentally switched the broadcast to a game from 1927. The kind of football game where if this was the first football game ever played in existence, there would be no second game played.

Thirty-eight points is a low number, but it’s low for a reason. I don’t need offensive brilliance. I need two teams to continue doing what they’ve already shown they can do
 make scoring touchdowns considerably more difficult than it should be.

Pick: Under 38

TCU +7.5 vs. Utah

Utah is 10-0, and I respect it. I also watched the Utes surrender 356 passing yards to Arizona and escape with a 40-39 win. That’s not a pass defense. That’s a revolving door with a Utes logo on it.

The numbers aren’t particularly flattering either. Utah ranks 119th nationally against the pass, allowing 246 yards per game through the air. That’s a pretty significant weakness to bring into a matchup with a TCU offense averaging 266 passing yards per game, good for 21st in the country. The Horned Frogs can attack the exact area where Utah has been most vulnerable, and that’s not something I’m interested in ignoring simply because the other team has a zero in the loss column.

TCU also has a defense worth taking seriously. The Frogs allow just 15.2 points per game, ranking 12th nationally, which gives them a realistic path to keeping this game within one possession. A capable passing attack, a legitimate defense, and more than a touchdown at home? That’s a combination I can get behind.

The line opened around 6.5 and has moved to 7.5. Whether that’s public enthusiasm for an undefeated Utah team or something else entirely, I’m happy to take the extra point. There’s a reason sportsbooks love undefeated teams this late in the season. Everybody sees the record, everybody remembers the highlights, and suddenly laying more than a touchdown on the road feels perfectly reasonable.

Not to me.

Utah might be the better team, but TCU has the tools to expose its biggest weakness and enough defense to prevent this from becoming a runaway. The Frogs don’t need to play a perfect game. They just need to make Utah uncomfortable, and I think they’re more than capable of doing that.

Give me the home dog. Give me the hook. And if TCU wins outright, don’t act like nobody warned you.

Pick: TCU +7.5

COSTANZA PICK OF THE WEEK: NEBRASKA +4 vs. Ohio State

Article image

“If every instinct you have is wrong, then the opposite would have to be right.”

George Costanza built an entire philosophy around doing the opposite of what made sense. Somehow, we’ve turned that philosophy into a betting strategy, which probably says more about us than it does about George.

Every instinct tells you to take Ohio State. They’ve won four straight meetings in this series. They’ve got Jeremiah Smith, they’ve got the helmets, they’ve got the reputation, and they’ve got the kind of program history that makes people automatically assume they’re going to win by three touchdowns whenever they see Nebraska on the schedule.

So naturally, we’re taking Nebraska.

This isn’t the Ohio State team people are accustomed to seeing. The Buckeyes are 7-3, with losses to Oregon and USC and a narrow 19-15 escape against Indiana. They’re talented, obviously, but the idea that the logo alone should scare us away from a home underdog is exactly the kind of thinking George Costanza would reject.

Nebraska’s defense has been excellent, allowing just 14.9 points per game compared with Ohio State’s 18.4. That’s not some meaningless statistic buried on page 47 of a media guide. It’s a legitimate reason to believe the Cornhuskers can keep this game competitive. The last meeting finished 21-17, and while Ohio State has controlled the series, these games haven’t always been the blowouts people expect.

Now factor in a noon kickoff in Lincoln, a sea of red, and an Ohio State team that knows exactly what’s waiting on the schedule next week. I’m not saying the Buckeyes will overlook Nebraska, but human nature is human nature. When you’ve got the biggest rivalry on your calendar coming up, it’s not unreasonable to wonder whether everybody’s attention is completely focused on the task at hand.

George walks into the diner, orders the chicken salad on rye, untoasted, with a side of potato salad and a cup of tea. It’s the opposite of everything he’d normally do, and somehow his life starts improving.

We’re not asking Nebraska to win the national championship. We’re asking the Cornhuskers to stay within a field goal at home against a team that hasn’t exactly been invincible.

Everything in your brain says Ohio State. George says Nebraska. And around here, we listen to George.

Costanza Pick: Nebraska +4

FINAL THOUGHTS

Six plays, one Costanza, and a Saturday that could either make us look like geniuses or have us questioning every decision we’ve made since breakfast.

We’ve got Washington and Kansas trying to make life miserable for ranked opponents, Boston College participating in something that technically qualifies as football, and TCU looking to ruin an undefeated team’s evening. Meanwhile, we’re asking Iowa, Illinois, UCLA, and Michigan to collectively forget that the end zone exists.

And then there’s Nebraska. Because apparently betting on George Costanza’s philosophy wasn’t enough of a warning sign that we’ve completely lost our minds.

That’s college football in November. The numbers get tighter, the games get uglier, and every team has something to play for, even if that something is simply making somebody else’s season miserable.

Good luck, trust your numbers, and may your unders stay under.

Mentally on IR. Where the picks are serious, even when absolutely nothing else is.

Bonus Lean: LSU vs. Tennessee UNDER 45.5

OFS JoeOFS Joe

Read Next